Why Meal Plans Often Don’t Work (and What to Do Instead)

 

How Meal Plans Can Lead to All-or-Nothing Thinking

Following a meal plan typically looks a little something like this:

You read over your meal plan, thinking that the food looks pretty good and you can definitely follow it all week, no problem. You head to the grocery store and get a little anxious trying to make sure you’re getting the exact matching ingredients from your grocery list (“it says brown rice, but is white rice ok!?”).

You head back home and prep your meals. A few hours later you have a full week of meals laid out in front of you. It’s great, because it means no brain power focusing on food choices for the rest of the week!

Mid-week you’re feeling a little burnt out on chicken and broccoli, but you know you can power through until the weekend.

Then, one night your friend wants to order takeout together, or your partner wants to cook a celebratory dinner, or you want to celebrate your kid’s birthday with cake and ice cream, and you think “now what?”

If the only option is to follow the meal plan exactly, it can feel like you have two choices: stick to the plan and miss out, or enjoy the occasion and feel like you’ve gone off the rails. That all-or-nothing thinking can make one meal feel like a setback, even though it doesn’t have to be.

A strict meal plan may not give you an alternative when it’s girls night, when you’re out for drinks after work, or when you’re on the road with your family.

MOST OF ALL, A STRICT MEAL PLAN OFTEN DOESN’T TAKE INTO ACCOUNT THAT LIFE IS CHAOTIC AND CONSTANTLY CHANGING.

There’s nothing wrong with eating the same thing often if you enjoy it. The problem is when there’s no room for flexibility when social events or family meals arise. That rigidity is what can make meal plans, and restrictive diets for that matter, unsustainable.

Why do meal plans often fail?

Strict meal plans can be hard to sustain because they leave little room for changing schedules, food preferences, and social events. A strict meal plan can make it harder to enjoy a work lunch, spend a weekend with family, or have last minute drinks with friends without feeling like you’re “off track.” When the only options feel like white-knuckling the rules or falling off the proverbial wagon, it can reinforce all-or-nothing thinking.

Instead of Following a Meal Plan, Learn to Plan Your Meals

Like our meal templates for new clients, an example meal template can be really helpful at first. But if you take a closer look at almost any meal plan, you’ll realize that most of them follow a similar pattern.

They are not random combinations of food, but balanced plates often include a protein + fat + carb source.

Start by choosing a few foods you enjoy from each category, then mix and match based on what you have and what your day looks like. If dinner plans change, you can use that same approach to choose a meal at a restaurant or enjoy takeout without feeling like you’ve failed.

There is so much power in understanding our food.

It allows us the knowledge and awareness to make the best choices for our goals regardless of our situation - whether we’re at home or ordering takeout - and that is what is sustainable.

Examples of Flexible Meals and Snacks

  • Breakfast: Overnight oats with oatmeal + protein powder + peanut butter

  • Snack: Greek yogurt + granola + berries

  • Lunch: Dave’s Killer Goodseed bread + turkey + cheese and condiments, with a side of carrots and cottage cheese

  • Snack: An RXBAR, on its own or paired with another food depending on your hunger and needs

  • Dinner: A skillet meal with chicken thigh + squash and Brussels sprouts + bacon

These are examples, not rules. Every meal or snack doesn’t need to look the same or include every component.

Kate Lyman in a kitchen

Nutrition tips that help simplify your food choices? We got you. Sign up to my weekly email for a bite-sized hit of coaching from me every Friday. Let’s make reaching your fat loss, health, and performance goals actually feel doable for you.

 
Previous
Previous

Creamy Chicken Tortilla Soup: A High-Protein, Low-Calorie Dinner​

Next
Next

Creating Habits That Stick: A Plan to Reach Your Nutrition Goals This Year